Captain America’s ‘Brave New World’ Is Here—And It’s Already a Controversial Flop

Another MCU movie stumbles. Captain America: Brave New World has officially landed on digital platforms after a theatrical run that can only be described as… underwhelming. With a dismal $413 million worldwide (pocket change for Marvel) and a Rotten Tomatoes score (48%) lower than Thor: The Dark World, the film is already being dragged into the franchise's hall of shame.

But here's the twist: screenwriter Rob Edwards thinks critics missed the point entirely.

The Numbers Don't Lie—But Do Critics?

Let's be real—$413 million is a disaster by Marvel's standards. For context:

• Ant-Man and The Wasp: Quantumania (another MCU low point) scraped past $476 million.
• Even The Incredible Hulk (2008) outgrossed Brave New World when adjusted for inflation.

And the reviews? Oof. That 48% RT score puts it just above Eternals (47%) and Quantumania (46%). Critics called it “soulless,” “messy,” and—worst of all—”forgettable.”

But Edwards isn't having it. In a recent interview, he fired back:

“Some of my friends who are critics, I said, ‘I think you guys missed it. I think you guys got it wrong.'”

So… did they?

Now Streaming: Your Chance to Judge

The movie's digital release (available now on Prime Video, Apple TV, etc.) comes packed with extras—deleted scenes, gag reels, behind-the-scenes footage. The real question: Will audiences see what Edwards claims critics ignored?

Marvel's track record suggests Brave New World will hit Disney+ by mid-May. But will anyone care by then?

The Bigger Problem: Marvel's Identity Crisis

This isn't just about one movie. Brave New World is the latest symptom of a franchise struggling to find its footing post-Endgame. Remember when Marvel movies were events? Now, they're just… content. And audiences are tuning out.

So—was this film unfairly maligned, or is it just another mediocre MCU entry? Now that it's at home, it's your turn to decide.

Check it out—then tell us: Did the critics get it wrong? Or did Marvel drop the shield?