FilmoFiliaFilmoFiliaFilmoFilia
  • News
  • Posters
  • Trailers
  • Photos
  • Red Carpet
  • Cannes Film Festival
  • More
    • Box Office
    • OSCAR Awards
    • Venice Film Festival
    • Movie Reviews
    • Interview
Reading: Materialists Hits $12M: Celine Song’s Second Act Stumbles—Or Does It?
Share
FilmoFiliaFilmoFilia
  • News
  • Posters
  • Trailers
  • Photos
  • Red Carpet
  • Cannes Film Festival
  • More
    • Box Office
    • OSCAR Awards
    • Venice Film Festival
    • Movie Reviews
    • Interview
Follow US
llusion is the first of all Pleasures. Copyright © 2007 - 2024 FilmoFilia
FilmoFilia > Movie News > Materialists Hits $12M: Celine Song’s Second Act Stumbles—Or Does It?
Movie News

Materialists Hits $12M: Celine Song’s Second Act Stumbles—Or Does It?

Materialists landed a $12M opening, but critics and fans are split: is Celine Song a rising auteur, or facing the dreaded sophomore slump?

Allan Ford June 15, 2025 Add a Comment
Celine Song Materialists

The Moment “Materialists” Stopped Breathing

It's Friday night, and “Materialists” is what's left on the shortlist after weeks of cinematic famine. I'm sitting two rows from the screen, popcorn cold, when Celine Song's second act magic kicks in—sharp, wounded dialogue that almost forgets it's supposed to be funny. The whole theater buzzy, tense, leaning forward like it's a thriller, not, as the marketing claims, a “romantic comedy.” That's already the first twist: this film is not what you expect. $5 million in one day, comfortably headed for a $12 million opening weekend—no small feat for a $20 million finance in this economy (and with everyone glued to “Inside Out 2” trailers).

Contents
The Moment “Materialists” Stopped BreathingSecond Films Are HauntedCritics, Fans, and Everyone Caught BetweenThe Bigger Picture—And What Comes Next

But then it trips. Hard. There's this subplot, clunky as a shopping cart wheel, that drags the last act somewhere safer and less honest. I almost heard the audience deflate, actual seats squeaking. Neat wrap-ups are supposed to feel like a sigh; here, it's a gasp that gets stuck. Maybe that's just me—though judging by the B- on CinemaScore, maybe not.

Second Films Are Haunted

Celine Song will never escape “Past Lives,” will she? (We all remember Past Lives. We downloaded every unofficial playlist people made on Spotify; that film left afterimages.) Here comes her second, not quite gunning for the same poetic heights, but wearing its Metacritic 70 like a—what? A badge, a bruise? Didn't matter, not this weekend: audiences showed up anyway. Industry folks kept one eye on the numbers, the other on the calendar—“Materialists” bowed nationally on June 14, 2024, fresh off limited June festival screenings, a rare thing for a RomCom in this era of IP bloat.

Screenshot at Materialists Reviews Metacritic

Read that again: the film made nearly half its production budget opening weekend, with nothing like Marvel money behind it. It's not “Barbenheimer,” it's not “Everything Everywhere…”—but I'd wager any director holding a $20 million ticket would kill for that opening.

Critics, Fans, and Everyone Caught Between

Critics like “Materialists,” fine. Not love. You can feel the caution in the reviews—a voice in the corner muttering “Sophomore slump?” while the rest of the room crosses their fingers. Not bad, says TheWrap. Not great, murmurs IndieWire. But grounded, always; nobody accuses Song of floating off into cliché, even if the ending feels suspiciously gift-wrapped. I felt that—watching a character dissolve into a resolution she didn't quite earn. Real people never get endings this tidy, do they?

On audience reaction: let's just call it split. There are mild laughs, some audible sighs, a bit of shuffling during the credits. That's your B- CinemaScore: good, not viral, not polarizing. For every “It's genius, you're all blind,” there's a “Well, Past Lives was better…”

The Bigger Picture—And What Comes Next

What does it mean for Celine Song? Is this the moment she gets pigeonholed—a one-hit wonder? Or is this second movie syndrome, the film that gets appreciated three years later, after the memes die down and someone writes a Medium essay about its quietly radical casting? Honestly, I don't know. No one does. Sometimes filmmakers stumble out of the gate twice, then catch fire. Sometimes… not.

Heard someone behind me whisper, “She's still better than 90% of the studio hacks.” Not wrong. Even if “Materialists” stumbles, it stumbles reaching for something—a messy, honest humanity. I'll take that over a dozen focus-grouped, committee-built streaming duds.

Look—Song isn't a one-hit wonder. Not yet. But all eyes are on her third act now.

You Might Also Like

A Dragon With Tired Wings — And Still, Nobody Touches It

Dragon Fire Beats Ohana: Why How To Train Your Dragon Just Torched Disney’s Lilo & Stitch at the Box Office

Celine Song Tackles E-Sports in HBO’s ‘Damage’

Dakota Johnson’s Love Triangle Turns Toxic in Celine Song’s NYC Romcom Mind Game

Why ‘Materialists’ Trailer Feels Like a 90s Rom-Com-And Why That’s a Risky Move

TAGGED:Celine SongMaterialists
Share This Article
Facebook Twitter Flipboard Pinterest Reddit Threads Copy Link
Previous Article In Your Dreams Netflix’s “In Your Dreams” trailer dives into absurd sibling fantasy with emotional bite
Next Article Squid Game Final Games Trailer: Squid Game 3 Ends in June
Leave a comment

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Latest News

Uwe Boll
Uwe Boll’s Latest Rant: A Masterclass in Self-Mythology or Desperation?
Movie News July 14, 2025
Paddington
Paddington with a Bullet: Inside James Gunn’s Beautifully Chaotic Video Store Mind
Movie News July 13, 2025
Donkey Kong Movie Moves Forward
The Kong Has Landed — But Is Anyone Asking for This Movie?
Movie News July 13, 2025

Latest Trailers

Cyberpunk Edgerunners II
Night City Returns, But at What Cost? ‘Edgerunners 2’ Teases a Bleaker, Bloodier Sequel
Movie Trailers July 13, 2025
A Spartan Dream
A Spartan Dream Got Festival Awards. And Now It’s a Guy Yelling at Athens in Flip-Flops?
Movie Trailers July 12, 2025
Traction Park Massacre
Traction Park Massacre Just Dropped Another Trailer. Why Are We Still Watching This?
Movie Trailers July 12, 2025

Latest Posters

Weapons Posters
Weapons Posters: Creepy, Confusing, and Kinda Brilliant
Movie Posters July 14, 2025
Superman Posters
A Cape, a Dog, and a Do-Over: James Gunn’s ‘Superman’ Posters Say More Than the Studio Realizes
Movie Posters July 14, 2025
Freakier Friday Posters
Freakier Friday Poster Chaos Unleashed
Movie Posters July 14, 2025

You Might also Like

Materialists
Movie PostersMovie Trailers

Dakota Johnson Navigates a High-Stakes Love Triangle in ‘Materialists’ Trailer

March 18, 2025

FIlmoFilia HOMEIllusion is the first of all Pleasures. Copyright © 2007 - 2025 FilmoFilia.

  • About FilmoFilia
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Sitemap
  • Contact Us
Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Lost your password?