Cristin Milioti Has “Zero Chill” About The Penguin Season 2 Return

Cristin Milioti doesn’t want you to forget her. “I feel like I have zero chill about it,” she told Variety, “because every time I’m asked [about a Season 2], I’m like, ‘Sign me up!’” The Emmy-winning actor, who plays Sofia Falcone in HBO’s The Penguin, was speaking at the premiere of her Netflix animated film In Your Dreams (voice cast includes Jolie Hoang-Rappaport, Elias Janssen, Craig Robinson, Simu Liu). Her tone is sincere, but it also sounds like someone who knows exactly what she’s risking if the series stalls. In a superhero TV world where momentum is currency, waiting is the hardest role.

The Penguin is the first and only spinoff emerging from Matt Reeves‘ 2022 The Batman, and its Season 2 has been on a quiet edge ever since. The reason is obvious and procedural: The Batman: Part II is scheduled to begin filming around April/May 2026. Reeves confirmed that Sofia won’t appear in that sequel. Until principal photography wraps, The Penguin’s Season 2 won’t move forward. It’s a sequencing problem disguised as a franchise decision—rooted in practical constraints and narrative continuity rather than creative whim.

The wait matters because Milioti’s Sofia Falcone left a scar. Her arc—released from Arkham after her father frames her for murders he committed, wrestling with family betrayal, forging a pact with Oz Cobb (Colin Farrell), then learning that Oz was behind her brother Alberto’s murder—drove much of the series’ emotional core. She reclaims her mother’s name under Gigante, aligns with Sal Maroni (Clancy Brown), and ultimately gets outmaneuvered by Oz, who ascends to Gotham’s underworld. The series ends with Sofia back in Arkham and a letter from Selina Kyle/Catwoman (Zoe Kravitz) that quietly nudges the bigger universe to widen its focus.

There’s something deliciously messy about Sofia’s power attempts. She’s both cunning and impulsive, capable of precision and violence in the same breath. That duality gave The Penguin its most intimate stakes; her struggle wasn’t just about territory—it was about dignity. In many ways, she felt like the emotional hinge of the show. And even if she isn’t in The Batman: Part II, her presence lingers as a mirror for Oz’s climb, Gotham’s brittle hierarchies, and the cost of family.

What’s The Penguin’s Season 2 hold? Officially, it’s dependent on The Batman: Part II finishing. Practically, that means continuity guardrails for Oswald Cobblepot’s rise, better understanding of Gotham’s altered map after Carmine Falcone’s removal, and a measured approach to scaling the spinoff without cannibalizing the sequel’s tone or timeline. Filming for Part II is slated to start around April/May 2026, with Kravitz returning. Until then, everything is on hold.

Fans are restless, and not just because The Penguin’s tone is bracing, grounded, and stylish. There’s a promise to this character space that feels underexplored—Sofia’s fractured identity, her vendetta turned inward, the ways Arkham both exposes and shelters Gotham’s broken. Milioti’s performance, which earned her an Emmy, has the kind of brittle intensity that makes you lean closer. You want her back because she made the series feel personal without collapsing it into melodrama.

It helps that The Penguin is grounded in the 2022 film’s realities. Carmine Falcone (John Turturro) was removed from the board by The Riddler (Paul Dano), leaving a vacuum that Oz exploits. Maroni emerges as a rival to that power bloc. Sofia—once framed—has her own claim to the Falcone legacy, which she ultimately renounces. That tangle of legacies and betrayals fuels the show’s moral weather. Put differently: The Penguin isn’t just a crime family story; it’s a study in how legacies are seized, abandoned, and reconstituted.

In Your Dreams, Milioti’s animated Netflix film, isn’t part of this continuity—but it’s a useful reminder of range. The cast—Jolie Hoang-Rappaport, Elias Janssen, Craig Robinson, Simu Liu—signals a tonal different beast, and premiering the movie created a natural moment for Milioti to discuss The Penguin Season 2 in a public forum. She spoke to Variety on that stage, circling back to how much she loves working with Lauren LeFranc and the show’s cast. The praise feels earned; the series’ ensemble was precisely tuned, often to its own detriment, because the stakes were so personal.

There’s an irony here. Milioti’s “zero chill” feeds excitement, but the very thing everyone loves about her performance is what makes The Penguin’s next steps so delicate. Audiences want more of Sofia because she complicates the world around her—more nuance, more bruises, more decisions that don’t clean themselves up easily. That appetite can become pressure. The question now is whether The Penguin’s Season 2, whenever it arrives, will preserve the intimacy and brutal clarity of Season 1 or broaden into the larger franchise map. On the merits, the former felt like the show’s heartbeat. The latter would be a strategic bet.

Given the sequencing, Season 2 is likely to be delayed beyond standard turnaround windows. Filming for The Batman: Part II starts around April/May 2026, and Season 2 won’t move until production wraps. In other words, the show isn’t delayed so much as deliberately sequenced. It’s a small but meaningful distinction, especially if the creative plan benefits from the extra runway—more prep time, more precision in stunt and production design, more care in calibrating character arcs so they don’t trip over the sequel’s tone.

So what’s driving the appetite to return? It’s the performance, but it’s also the architecture of a world where power isn’t handed down, it’s pried away. In The Penguin, authority gets stripped in plain sight. Sofia’s letter from Selina in Arkham is a tiny narrative hinge—soft, almost negligible, yet meaningful as a signal that the universe is still moving. It tells us Sofia’s isolation might be temporary, or that her identity—Falcone vs Gigante—will continue to matter. Without explicit access to Season 2 plans, we can read that moment as a tether: a promise to the audience that even in containment, connections endure.

Fans should temper expectations with honesty. The Batman: Part II will shape the backdrop of whatever The Penguin Season 2 becomes, even if Sofia doesn’t appear in the sequel itself. That backdrop will dictate tone, pacing, and plausible arcs for Oz’s ascent, Maroni’s faction, and Sofia’s evolution. In short: excitement is justified, patience is required. This isn’t a production stall—it’s a carefully orchestrated timeline, and patience here is part of the craft.

For now, In Your Dreams is streaming on Netflix. The Penguin’s Season 2 remains tethered to the sequel’s shooting schedule, which begins around April/May 2026. Fans can safely assume Season 2 won’t proceed until principal photography wraps, and Milioti’s Sofia won’t show up in The Batman: Part II. That’s the current, confirmed boundary. What happens inside those boundaries will likely depend on how the creative team chooses to let Gotham’s weather continue—cold, loud, complicated, and unforgiving.

Summary Recap

• Sofia Falcone’s arc gave The Penguin its most intimate stakes, with Milioti’s Emmy‑winning performance anchoring both family betrayal and personal vendetta.
• The Penguin Season 2 is officially dependent on The Batman: Part II finishing, with filming for the sequel slated to start around April/May 2026.
• Reeves confirmed Sofia won’t appear in The Batman: Part II; The Penguin’s next steps won’t move until after principal photography wraps.
• At the In Your Dreams premiere, Milioti said she has “zero chill” about returning, citing love for Lauren LeFranc and the ensemble.
• That letter from Selina in Arkham functions as a quiet narrative hinge—intimating connections that outlast immediate power shifts.

FAQ