The Independent's 60 Best Actors of the 21st Century: A Dive Into Controversy
Lists like The Independent's “60 Best Actors of the 21st Century” are always tricky. Designed to celebrate greatness, they often tread the thin line between homage and provocation. This particular ranking, with its eclectic mix of performers, has ignited fierce discussions in cinephile circles. The late Philip Seymour Hoffman secures the #1 spot, a testament to his unparalleled ability to bring depth and humanity to every role. But was he truly the greatest of his era? Let's dissect this ranking and its implications.
The Top 10: A Puzzle of Picks
The top 10 showcases a curious mix of veterans and rising stars:
1) Philip Seymour Hoffman – A master of subtlety and emotional depth, Hoffman's work in films like Capote and The Master cements his legacy.
2) Emma Stone – While undeniably talented, with standout roles in La La Land and Birdman, does she outrank Cate Blanchett or Nicole Kidman?
3) Daniel Day-Lewis – The only actor to win three Best Actor Oscars, Day-Lewis' exclusion from the #1 spot is baffling.
4) Denzel Washington – A powerhouse of charisma and intensity, his work spans decades of excellence.
5) Nicole Kidman – A chameleon of the screen, Kidman's roles in The Hours and Big Little Lies showcase her range.
6) Daniel Kaluuya – A rising star, Kaluuya's inclusion in the top 10 feels premature despite stellar performances in Get Out and Judas and the Black Messiah.
7) Song Kang Ho – The South Korean actor's nuanced performances in Parasite and Memories of Murder deserve recognition.
8) Cate Blanchett – A perennial favorite, her omission from the top 5 feels unjust.
9) Colin Farrell – From action roles to indie dramas, Farrell's versatility earns him a spot.
10) Florence Pugh – A dynamic performer, but is she ready for top 10 status?
Notable Exclusions
The absence of legends like Meryl Streep, Brad Pitt, and Heath Ledger raises eyebrows. Meryl's omission is particularly glaring, given her consistent brilliance in films like The Iron Lady and Doubt. Similarly, why do Gary Oldman, Cillian Murphy, and Jake Gyllenhaal languish outside the list altogether?
Questionable Placements
Tom Cruise (#60) and Ralph Fiennes (#53) feel woefully underrated, given their contributions to both blockbuster and arthouse cinema. On the other hand, Jason Schwartzman's high ranking (#37) is puzzling, especially when compared to the likes of Leonardo DiCaprio (#17) and Michelle Williams (#18).
The Full List
1) Philip Seymour Hoffman
2) Emma Stone
3) Daniel Day-Lewis
4) Denzel Washington
5) Nicole Kidman
6) Daniel Kaluuya
7) Song Kang Ho
8) Cate Blanchett
9) Colin Farrell
10) Florence Pugh
11) Natalie Portman
12) Willem Dafoe
13) Isabelle Huppert
14) Christian Bale
15) Jennifer Lawrence
16) Kristen Stewart
17) Leonardo DiCaprio
18) Michelle Williams
19) Kirsten Dunst
20) Tilda Swinton
21) Tony Leung
22) Adam Driver
23) Penélope Cruz
24) Jesse Plemons
25) Carey Mulligan
26) Joaquin Phoenix
27) Paul Giamatti
28) Saoirse Ronan
29) Mahershala Ali
30) Rachel McAdams
31) Ryan Gosling
32) Frances McDormand
33) Mark Ruffalo
34) Michael Stuhlbarg
35) Robert Pattinson
36) Adèle Haenel
37) Jason Schwartzman
38) Viggo Mortensen
39) Viola Davis
40) Javier Bardem
41) Irrfan Khan
42) Tom Hardy
43) Andrew Garfield
44) Robert Downey Jr.
45) Kate Winslet
46) Lupita Nyong'o
47) Léa Seydoux
48) Tom Hanks
49) Sandra Hüller
50) Olivia Colman
51) Andy Serkis
52) Lesley Manville
53) Ralph Fiennes
54) Sally Hawkins
55) Matthew McConaughey
56) Catherine Keener
57) Hugh Grant
58) Stephen Graham
59) Amy Adams
60) Tom Cruise
Personal Impressions
The Independent's list is a mixed bag—equal parts celebration and provocation. While it rightfully highlights underappreciated talent like Song Kang Ho and Michael Stuhlbarg, its snubs and placements seem designed to spark outrage. Hoffman's position at the top is well-deserved, but the omissions of Meryl Streep and Brad Pitt are indefensible.
Do you agree with The Independent's ranking? Which actors would you move up, and who do you feel deserved inclusion? Share your thoughts below!
