The world of cinema is no stranger to controversy, but how far should film festivals go in avoiding it? That question resurfaced when the Toronto International Film Festival (TIFF) reportedly turned down September 5, a dramatic thriller centered around the 1972 Munich Olympics terrorist attack, where Palestinian militants took Israeli athletes hostage. The decision, apparently driven by fear of sparking Israeli-Palestinian controversy, has raised eyebrows in both the film and political spheres.
Directed by Tim Fehlbaum (The Colony), September 5 had already garnered buzz after screenings at Venice and Telluride. With stars like Peter Sarsgaard, John Magaro, and Leonie Benesch leading the cast, the film tells the harrowing story from the perspective of ABC Sports' broadcasters, as they cover the tragic events unfolding in Munich. The buzz culminated in a splashy deal with Paramount, but TIFF, wary of backlash, chose to sidestep the potential controversy — an avoidance strategy that some are calling “cowardice at its finest.”
It's worth noting that TIFF previously screened Russians at War, a documentary offering a sympathetic portrayal of Russian soldiers, which led to significant protests. While Russians at War was eventually pulled from the lineup, the decision to reject September 5 altogether seems inconsistent, especially given its potential for Oscar glory. With early predictions already leaning toward a Best Picture nomination, TIFF's decision may go down as one of its biggest missteps this season.
Set to make waves during awards season, September 5 is a film that tackles complex global issues while offering a gripping cinematic experience. While TIFF opted to avoid the heat, movie lovers should brace for a film that's sure to stir conversations well beyond its narrative. Whether or not it generates controversy, it's bound to leave an impact.
And that, in itself, is what great cinema should do.
