‘I Want You Back’ Review: 7 Outrageously Honest Reasons This Comedy Actually Works

Let's be brutally honest—most romantic comedies these days feel like reheated leftovers. Bland. Predictable. About as fresh as a 90s sitcom marathon. But then along comes I Want You Back, a film so gleefully chaotic, it feels like someone shoved a Hallmark movie into a blender with a bottle of tequila and said, “Go nuts.”

And go nuts it does.

---

Why ‘I Want You Back‘ Is Actually A Great Comedy

Because Charlie Day and Jenny Slate are your new sad clown power couple

If you've ever seen Charlie Day scream in It's Always Sunny or Jenny Slate bring awkward brilliance to Obvious Child, you know these two don't do rom-coms the normal way. They're not rom-com pretty. They're panic-attack-on-a-first-date pretty. They bring the energy of people who've read too many Reddit threads about getting their exes back—and then actually tried it.

The chemistry? Hilarious. Romantic? Uh… let's call it “friend-zoned with benefits.” The script says they fall for each other, but honestly, it's like watching your two most chaotic friends turn codependency into a buddy system.

---

Because the premise is diabolically relatable

Peter and Emma get dumped. So what do they do? Therapy? No. Eat ice cream? Also no. They plot revenge. Obviously.

Emma tries to break up Peter's ex's new relationship. Peter befriends Emma's ex to sabotage him from the inside. This isn't just stalking. This is full-on espionage… with jazz hands.

Their methods? Bonkers. Peter becomes gym buddies with Scott Eastwood (bless his abs), while Emma fakes a friendship with Gina Rodriguez's new boyfriend to tear them apart.

It's a rom-com with the soul of a heist movie. Only dumber. And way more fun.

---

Because one scene will literally make you spit your drink

Let's talk about that scene. The threesome one.

No spoilers, but imagine the worst possible way a person could try to be sexy, and then double it. That's what Jenny Slate does. There's furniture falling, identity confusion, possibly a pulled hamstring—and Charlie Day popping out of a closet like a drunk jack-in-the-box.

You won't laugh. You'll wheeze.

---

Because it has more heart than it has any right to

Underneath the sabotage, karaoke, drugs, and misplaced flirtation, there's actual emotional depth. Like, real feelings.

Emma befriends a lonely middle schooler. Peter tries to improve life at an old folks' home. These moments aren't just filler. They make you root for these hot messes. You want them to heal. Preferably without more karaoke.

---

Because it doesn't make the exes villains

Here's where I Want You Back pulls a sneaky move—it doesn't make the new partners evil.

Scott Eastwood and Gina Rodriguez are likable. Too likable. Like, “Why did you dump these people again?” likable. It flips the typical rom-com trope and makes you realize… maybe Peter and Emma were the problem?

And that's when it hits you: this isn't a rom-com about getting your ex back. It's about getting over yourself.

---

Because the humor is weird, awkward, and perfectly timed

Some jokes fall flat—sure. But when it hits, it hits like a Nerf dart to the eyeball.

Highlights include:

• A gym pep talk that turns into a meltdown
• An excruciatingly earnest retirement home pitch (“Bingo… but SEXIER”)
• Peter accidentally dropping acid before a school event (nothing says “red flag” like hallucinating during jazz band)

Also, shout-out to the one-liner about “getting back on the whores”—a total misfire, but honestly, it's so bad it loops back to hilarious.

---

Because it's beautifully shot for a movie about emotional dumpster fires

Shot during COVID, the film never feels restricted. The direction by Jason Orley is clean, bright, and oddly comforting. The score by Siddhartha Khosla adds nostalgic charm, as if someone whispered, “Make this feel like a 90s rom-com but with better lighting.”

---

Interesting Trivia: Bet You Didn't Know This

• Pete Davidson makes a cameo as an ex-con theater nerd. Yes, it's exactly as weird as it sounds.
• Filmed in early 2021, the production had to work around tight COVID restrictions.
• Jenny Slate originally voiced the character of Missy in Big Mouth—until she stepped down to support diversity casting.
• Charlie Day once said in an interview that he based Peter's retirement home dream on his real-life admiration for elder care workers.

---

FAQs

Is “I Want You Back” worth watching?
Absolutely. It's awkward, messy, and ridiculously entertaining—just like a real breakup.

Is this a typical rom-com?
Nope. It's a rom-com for people who roll their eyes at rom-coms.

Is there romance?
Yes. But the bromance between Day and Eastwood? Even better.

What's the best scene in the movie?
The acid trip at the middle school event. It's chaos in khakis.

Is the ending predictable?
Kind of. But the journey there is delightfully off-road.

Would this movie make a good date night watch?
Only if your date has a dark sense of humor and an ex they secretly want to stalk.

---

Closer

So here's the deal: I Want You Back is not perfect. But that's the point. It's a love letter to emotional messes, to bad decisions, to the part of you that thinks, “Hey, maybe I can win them back with karaoke.”

You'll either laugh, cringe, or both. But you will relate. And maybe, just maybe, you'll realize it's okay to let go—and laugh at yourself along the way.

Go watch it. Then call your ex and don't say a word. Just send them a clip of Jenny Slate bombing a threesome.

Looking for a good laugh? This film has earned its spot on our carefully curated list of The Best Comedies on Prime Video ! If you're in the mood for more chuckles, check out the full lineup. From witty banter to side-splitting antics, we've got something for every comedy lover. Dive in and discover your next favorite feel-good movie—because laughter truly is the best medicine!